CAA: Christian Anime Alliance

which of the this is halloween song do you like best

Got to go with the original. I hate Marilyn Manson with a passion. The guy ruins every song he covers! Not to mention the whole "satanism" thing.

The manson version, the only good music he makes are covers of other good music.

Close call. I actually didn't (don't) like the Marylin cover when I just hear it by itself, but that AMV you linked to scares the bejeepers outta be when I watch it! Every time! The original version just doesn't quite have that effect, and scary is what Halloween is all about.

I like the Manson version more, but only because the AMV is so good. Otherwise, I prefer the original.

In my opinion, Panic! At the Disco's cover doesn't even stand up to the others...

I like the original the best. Danny Elfman's music is just incredible. The different singers give it a more whimsical feel, and it's more like discovering a story than listening to a song alone.

Marilyn Manson's cover was hardcore and well done though... even if what he stands for gives me the creeps.

I like Danny Elfman's version. When I listen to it, I can see Halloweentown in my head. The other versions just make me imagine being at a concert.

Beau Soir wrote:Marilyn Manson's cover was hardcore and well done though... even if what he stands for gives me the creeps.

The Food Pyramid gives you the creeps?

am i the only one who liked panic! at the disco's version?

Nate (post: 1459904) wrote:The Food Pyramid gives you the creeps?

This remains my favorite thing Manson has ever done.

elfman, Only because i've heard mansions version way to many times and the Panic at the disco one was pretty bad

Close call btween Manson and Diso, if only based on the song, I probably would have chose Disco, but I am biased toward the creepiness of Soul Eater, I know that is the video I am sending to everyone next Halloween.